Last updated: 14 October 2026 · By Dhruv Patil · Sources checked: 14 Oct 2026
Disclosure: TeenBucks may earn a commission if you open an account through some links marked “affiliate”. That never changes the order or what we say. The comparison follows the criteria under “How we compared”, not payouts. This is general information, not personal financial advice. Banks change fees, so check the official link before you apply.
The 30-second answer
- “Zero balance” only means no penalty for a low balance. It doesn’t mean “no fees at all”. The real costs usually hide in debit card annual fees, ATM withdrawals past the free limit, and SMS or cash charges.
- Under 18? You need a minor account (for example SBI Pehla Kadam or Pehli Udaan), opened with a parent or guardian’s KYC. Most app-only “instant” accounts are 18+ only.
- 18+ and comfortable with apps? Digital zero-balance accounts (Kotak 811, IDFC FIRST Quantum+) open by video KYC, but they ask for PAN + Aadhaar.
- No PAN? Go to a branch and ask for a Basic Savings Bank Deposit (BSBD) account, or a student account that accepts the Form 97 declaration (it replaced Form 60 in April 2026).
- There’s no single “best” account. The right one depends on your age, whether you need cash and a physical card, and whether you have a PAN.
The accounts compared (all figures from official pages, checked 14 Oct 2026)
Each account gets its own short card below, so it reads well on a phone.

SBI Basic Savings Bank Deposit (BSBD)
- Who can open: “All individuals having valid KYC documents”
- Minimum balance: Nil; no upper limit on balance
- Debit card cost: basic RuPay ATM-cum-debit card free, no annual maintenance charge
- Free cash / ATM limits: 4 free withdrawals a month, counting own/other-bank ATMs, branch and AEPS together; after that ₹15 + GST per withdrawal (digital transactions excluded)
- How you open it: branch
- PAN needed? Rule 159 doesn’t require PAN/Form 97 to open a BSBD; for SBI’s own paperwork: Check with the bank
- Official source: SBI BSBD · SBI ATM charges notice (PDF), checked 14 Oct 2026
Bank of Baroda bob BRO Savings (students)
- Who can open: resident students aged 16–25; joint with parent/guardian allowed
- Minimum balance: Zero (QAB); zero penalty
- Debit card cost: RuPay Platinum debit card: lifetime-free issuance & renewal
- Free cash / ATM limits: 5 free txns at BoB ATMs (financial + non-financial), then ₹10 financial / ₹5 non-financial. Other banks’ ATMs: 3 metro / 5 non-metro free, then ₹23 financial / ₹11 non-financial
- How you open it: branch (all branches)
- PAN needed? Page says “PAN/Form 60 mandatory” (now Form 97)
- Official source: BoB BRO · BoB service charges, checked 14 Oct 2026
Kotak 811 (Full KYC)
- Who can open: resident individuals 18+
- Minimum balance: Nil non-maintenance charge
- Debit card cost: first virtual card free, then ₹49 per issuance. Physical Dream Different card ₹399 issuance + ₹399 a year (GST incl.), replacement ₹299
- Free cash / ATM limits: 5 txns at Kotak ATMs; other ATMs 3 (metro) / 5 (non-metro); after that ₹23 per financial / ₹10 per non-financial txn (the GSFC says charges are excl. GST unless stated)
- How you open it: app + video KYC
- PAN needed? Not listed on the eligibility page (it lists only 18+ and resident Indian): Check with the bank
- Official source: Eligibility · GSFC from 1 Jul 2026 (PDF), checked 14 Oct 2026
IDFC FIRST Quantum+ Savings
- Who can open: resident individuals 18+, new-to-bank only (not for anyone who has ever held an IDFC FIRST SA/FD)
- Minimum balance: AMB Nil
- Debit card cost: Visa Classic card free in year 1, ₹300 a year from year 2, replacement ₹300
- Free cash / ATM limits: IDFC FIRST ATMs free; other banks’ ATMs: first 5 free, then ₹23 financial / ₹8 non-financial per txn
- How you open it: app only (video KYC)
- PAN needed? Yes, PAN + Aadhaar-linked mobile mandatory
- Official source: Product page · Fees & charges, checked 14 Oct 2026
Airtel Payments Bank Savings (payments bank)
- Who can open: 18+: T&C require users to be “at least 18 years of age”
- Minimum balance: No minimum balance, but account maintenance charge ₹99 + 18% GST per quarter (₹49 + GST with DBT credits in the past 6 months)
- Debit card cost: Check with the bank (not on the charges page)
- Free cash / ATM limits: cash withdrawal free up to ₹10,000 a month (cumulative), then 0.65% of the amount. SMS: first 100 a month free, then ₹0.35 + GST each
- How you open it: Airtel Thanks app (CKYC + liveness check + UPI money load)
- PAN needed? Yes, PAN + Aadhaar. Account facilitation charge: ₹199 incl. GST per the charges table (checked 14 Oct 2026)
- Official source: Charges · T&C · Product, checked 14 Oct 2026
Payments-bank fine print: RBI caps a payments bank’s end-of-day balance at ₹2,00,000. Airtel sets its own lower cap of ₹1,92,000 (or ₹1,97,000 with a Suryoday SFB sweep account). Payments banks can’t give loans or credit cards. (Airtel T&C, checked 14 Oct 2026)
How we compared: the total yearly cost for a typical student (card fee + likely ATM use), whether the account is open to under-18s, whether you can open it without PAN, and how strict the limits are. Accounts are grouped by how you open them (branch first, then app). They aren’t ranked by commission.
Why this matters to you: two “zero balance” accounts can cost you very different amounts in a year. The card and ATM lines are where the difference shows up.

BSBD fine print most blogs skip
From SBI’s own BSBD page (checked 14 Oct 2026):
- You can’t hold any other savings account at SBI alongside a BSBD. If you already have one, it must be closed within 30 days.
- No cheque book. You withdraw with a withdrawal form at the branch, or at ATMs.
- 4 free cash withdrawals a month in total: SBI ATMs, other banks’ ATMs, the branch and AEPS all count towards it.
- Free: the RuPay card (no AMC), NEFT/RTGS credits, reactivating an inoperative account, and closing the account.
Under 18 vs 18+: what actually changes
| Under 18* | 18 and above | |
|---|---|---|
| Who signs | Parent/guardian, or the minor alone from about age 10 at some banks | You |
| KYC | Minor’s date-of-birth proof + parent’s KYC (SBI) | Your own KYC (Aadhaar/PAN, etc.) |
| Online/video KYC | Usually not; plan for a branch visit | Common (Kotak 811, IDFC FIRST, Airtel) |
| Limits | Daily caps on card/UPI/net banking | Normal product limits |
| At 18 | The account must be converted to a major account with fresh KYC | n/a |
*Minor account.
SBI Pehla Kadam & Pehli Udaan (SBI minors page, checked 14 Oct 2026):
- Pehla Kadam: for a minor of any age, opened jointly with a parent/guardian.
- Pehli Udaan: for minors above 10 who can sign the same way every time. Opened in the minor’s sole name.
- No monthly average balance needed. Maximum balance ₹10 lakh.
- Photo ATM-cum-debit card with a ₹5,000 withdrawal/POS limit. Mobile banking limit ₹2,000 a day.
- KYC: minor’s date-of-birth proof + parent’s KYC.
- Debit card annual fee for minors: SBI’s general schedule lists ₹200 + GST a year from year 2 for Classic/Silver/Global/Contactless cards (SBI debit card charges, checked 14 Oct 2026). It doesn’t say whether this applies to Pehla Kadam / Pehli Udaan photo cards, so Check with the bank.
Bank of Baroda bob BRO starts at 16. For minors aged 10–14 operating on their own, the maximum balance is ₹1 lakh (BoB BRO, checked 14 Oct 2026).
Turning 18 at college? Convert your minor account (with fresh KYC) before you open a new zero-balance account. If you’re opening a BSBD, remember the one-savings-account rule at that bank.
KYC documents checklist
RBI calls these “Officially Valid Documents” (OVDs). Bank of Baroda’s page lists them as: passport, driving licence with photo, proof of possession of Aadhaar number, voter ID, NREGA job card signed by a State Government officer, and a National Population Register letter with name and address (BoB BRO, checked 14 Oct 2026). On top of that:
- PAN, or Form 97 if you don’t have PAN (see below)
- A recent photo
- For minors: date-of-birth proof + parent/guardian KYC
- For digital accounts: an Aadhaar-linked mobile number for OTP, and the original PAN card for the video KYC call (IDFC FIRST lists this)
- College ID: Bank of Baroda’s BRO page lists a college/institution ID card, an admission letter, or a hostel allotment letter among accepted local-address documents. That list sits under its foreign-student documents (BoB BRO, checked 14 Oct 2026). For Indian students, whether a college ID is required or just accepted: Check with the bank.
No PAN? How to open an account (Form 97, formerly Form 60)
- Since 1 April 2026, under the Income-tax Rules 2026, someone without PAN fills in Form No. 97, which replaced Form 60 (Income Tax Dept: Form 97 & 98 (old 60 & 61); Rule 159, checked 14 Oct 2026).
- According to the Income Tax Department’s summary of Rule 159, quoting PAN (or filing Form 97) applies to opening a bank account other than a basic savings bank deposit account or time deposit. So BSBD is outside that PAN requirement. Banks can still ask for their own documents, so confirm at the branch.
- A minor with no taxable income can quote a parent’s or guardian’s PAN (Rule 159).
- App-only accounts usually won’t take Form 97. IDFC FIRST Quantum+, Kotak 811 and Airtel Payments Bank all list PAN as required. Without PAN, plan for a branch visit.
- If a branch hands you an old “Form 60”, ask whether they’ve moved to Form 97. Some bank pages haven’t been updated yet. You’ll need proof of identity, address and date of birth with the declaration.
- Longer term: apply for a PAN. You’ll need it anyway for a demat account, a credit card or mutual funds, and Form 97 isn’t allowed for those.
Why this matters to you: not having a PAN yet doesn’t lock you out of banking. It just means a branch visit instead of an app.
Hidden-fee checklist (ask about each one before you sign)
- ☐ Debit card issuance + annual fee (e.g. Kotak 811 physical ₹399 a year; IDFC FIRST ₹300 a year from year 2; SBI BSBD and BoB BRO free)
- ☐ Replacement card fee (Kotak ₹299, IDFC ₹300)
- ☐ Free ATM count and the fee after it (IDFC, Kotak and BoB: ₹23 per financial txn at other banks’ ATMs after the free ones; SBI BSBD: ₹15 + GST after 4)
- ☐ Monthly cash withdrawal cap (SBI BSBD: 4 in total)
- ☐ Balance or credit caps (payments bank ₹2 lakh; Kotak 811 Limited KYC has limits)
- ☐ SMS alert charges (Kotak: free limit of 30 SMS a month; IDFC: free)
- ☐ Declined-transaction fee for insufficient balance (Kotak: ₹25 per instance, virtual or physical card; GSFC, checked 14 Oct 2026)
- ☐ International ATM fee (IDFC ₹125 per txn) and currency mark-up
- ☐ Cash@PoS (Kotak: 1% + GST)
- ☐ One-account rule (BSBD) and new-to-bank rule (IDFC Quantum+)
- ☐ Maintenance charges on “no minimum balance” accounts (Airtel Payments Bank: ₹99 + GST per quarter; charges, checked 14 Oct 2026)
- ☐ Account conversion rules: BoB lets existing Baroda Champ (SB156) accounts convert to BRO, and BRO can move to another scheme on that scheme’s terms (BoB BRO, checked 14 Oct 2026). What happens to a BRO account after age 25: Check with the bank. SBI says BSBD holders who need more services can convert to a normal savings account at the applicable charges (SBI service charges PDF, checked 14 Oct 2026). At any other bank, ask and get the answer in writing.
How to choose (there’s no single “best”)
- Under 18? Your only route is a minor account with a parent. SBI Pehla Kadam / Pehli Udaan is one documented example.
- No PAN? Go for a branch BSBD, or a student account with Form 97.
- Need cash often, or a physical card? Free-card options like SBI BSBD and BoB BRO keep your yearly cost lowest. Keep BSBD’s 4-withdrawal cap in mind.
- Mostly UPI/online, 18+, have PAN? A digital account works if you stick to the virtual card. Paying for a physical card turns a “zero” account into ₹300–₹399 a year.
- Want a second “UPI-only” account? Payments banks suit small daily spends. But there’s a ₹2 lakh cap, no loans, and possibly a quarterly maintenance charge (Airtel: ₹99 + GST).
- Read the schedule of charges (linked in each card above) before you apply, not after.
Related guides
- SBI BSBD account for students: the full rules, limits and charges for SBI’s basic savings account
- Zero-fee demat accounts for students (this one needs a PAN)
- Budgeting for students
FAQ
Is a zero balance account really free?
There’s no penalty for a low balance, but other fees can still apply. Think debit card annual fees (for example ₹399 a year for Kotak 811’s physical card), ATM use past the free limit, replacement cards, and at some payments banks a quarterly maintenance charge (Airtel Payments Bank: ₹99 + GST). Check the bank’s schedule of charges.
Which bank is best for a student zero balance account?
It depends on your age, whether you have a PAN, and how you bank. Under-18s need a minor account. Without PAN, a branch BSBD is the usual route. If you use apps and have a PAN, a digital account works, as long as you stick to the free virtual card.
Can I open a bank account under 18 in India?
Yes, as a minor account. At SBI, Pehla Kadam is opened jointly with a parent at any age, and Pehli Udaan in the minor’s own name above age 10. Both need the minor’s date-of-birth proof and the parent’s KYC.
Can I open a bank account without a PAN card?
Often yes, at a branch. A Basic Savings Bank Deposit account is outside the PAN-quoting rule for bank accounts. For other accounts you can fill in Form 97, which replaced Form 60 from 1 April 2026. Most app-only accounts still need a PAN.
What is the difference between Form 60 and Form 97?
Form 97 is the new no-PAN declaration under the Income-tax Rules 2026. It replaced Form 60 from 1 April 2026.
Can I open a zero balance account online without visiting a branch?
Yes, if you’re 18+ and have a PAN and an Aadhaar-linked mobile. Kotak 811, IDFC FIRST Quantum+ and Airtel Payments Bank open through an app. Minors and people without PAN usually need a branch.
Can I hold a BSBD account and another savings account at the same bank?
Not at SBI. SBI’s BSBD terms say you can’t hold any other savings account there, and an existing one must be closed within 30 days.
What happens to my minor account when I turn 18?
The bank will ask you to update your KYC and convert it to a regular account. Do this before you open any new account.
